Carr, as well as to his opponents like Leonard Schapiro, that the Russian Revolution mattered.
- Published in.
- Log in to Wiley Online Library.
- RapidIO: The Embedded System Interconnect!
- Free Thought Lives!
- Linux Performance Tuning and Capacity Planning (Kaleidoscope).
- Writing the Stalin Era: Sheila Fitzpatrick and Soviet Historiography?
- Writing the history of the Stalin era: An interview with Sheila Fitzpatrick on Apple Podcasts.
It mattered to Schapiro because it had imposed a new political tyranny on Russia that threatened the free world, and to Carr because it had pioneered the centralised state-planned economy that he saw as a portent of the future. Who cares now about building smoke-stack industries, except in a context of polluting the environment? It has taught us what does not work. It is hard to see Marxism making any sort of comeback. As a theory of history the revolution tested it, and it failed.
The dictatorship of the proletariat did not lead to the communist utopia, but merely to more dictatorship. It also failed as a prescription for economic governance.
What is Kobo Super Points?
No serious economist today is advocating total state ownership as the route to prosperity … not the least of the lessons of the Russian Revolution is that for most economic purposes the market works much better than the state. The rush away from socialism since has been Gadarene.
If the Russian Revolution had any lasting achievement, he adds, it is probably China. Smith, in more cautious terms, makes a similar assessment:. In this respect the record of the Chinese Communists in promoting their country to the rank of a leading economic and political world power was far more impressive than that of the regime on which it broadly modelled itself.
Indeed, as the 21st century advances, it may come to seem that the Chinese Revolution was the great revolution of the 20th century. Perhaps by the time of the bicentenary Russia will have worked out a way to salvage it, as the risk of losing a chapter in the world history of the 20th century is surely one that no patriotic regime should ignore. By , who knows what people will think? Log In Register for Online Access.
She has taken risks with arguments and types of arguments, but most of her main postulates - about social support for the Stalin regime and its contribution to the longevity and relative stability of the Soviet state; about the factions within the cultural worlds and the politics of Soviet bureaucracy - have held up and entered the mainstream of research and teaching about the Soviet period.
I think it is inconceivable today for anyone to seriously prepare graduate students in the field without a thorough exposure to Fitzpatrick's contributions. Help Centre. My Wishlist Sign In Join. Be the first to write a review. Add to Wishlist. Ships in 15 business days. Link Either by signing into your account or linking your membership details before your order is placed. Description Table of Contents Product Details Click on the cover image above to read some pages of this book! Industry Reviews "This well-deserved tribute to a great historian is a fascinating read for any specialist of the USSR we have learned so much from her" - Cahiers du Monde Russe "Sheila Fitzpatrick has indeed helped to shape generations of historians of twentieth century Russia in their understanding of Soviet politics, the evolution of the Russian revolution, the inner workings of Stalinism, and lately the dynamics of everyday forms of resistance under Stalinism.
All Rights Reserved.
Applebaum vs. Fitzpatrick: Is History Political?
Stalinism: New Directions. London: Routledge. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. Bloomington, Ind. Armonk, NY: Routledge.
Book Chapters Fitzpatrick, S. In Alena Ledeneva Eds.
- REVISIONISM IN SOVIET HISTORY.
- American Historical Review.
- Chicano Rap: Gender and Violence in the Postindustrial Barrio.
- Get PDF Writing the Stalin Era: Sheila Fitzpatrick and Soviet Historiography.
- RELATED CATEGORIES!
London: UCL Press. Annexation, Evacuation, and Antisemitism in the Soviet Union, In Choi Chatterjee, David L. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. Popular Opinion under Communist Regimes. Smith Eds. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Stalin and the World of Culture.
Baratieri, M. Finaldi Eds. New York: Routledge. The Cold War as remembered by the children of the Old Left. Personal Stories from a Troubled Time , pp. Sydney: NewSouth Publishing.
- Biographical details.
- Service Enterprise Integration: An Enterprise Engineering Perspective.
- Writing the Stalin era : Sheila Fitzpatrick and Soviet historiography - Ghent University Library!
- On Stalin’s Team by Sheila Fitzpatrick review – Soviet bunglers and sadists | Books | The Guardian;
Afterword: The Thaw in Retrospect. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Der Tod des Subjekts und seine Folgen.
Kucher, G. Thun, S.
source link Urbansky Eds. Frankfurt: Campus Verlag. Politica como pratica. Uma nova abordagem a historia politica sovietica. Borges Pereira Eds. Lisbon: Edicoes 70, Lda.